Thanks to my friend Ben, I’ve realized that something very much like those questionnaires of early email days—cousins to the slam books of twentieth-century high schoolers that demanded the recipient write their answers to innocuous personal questions before being passed on to the next eager viewer or participant—has been going around in the form of a challenge to lay out your “personal canon of twenty songs.”
At one point in my life, I would have jumped right in; I was, after all, a champion mix-maker, one of those over-invested dorks who handcrafted covers and liner notes for both cassettes and then CDs, playing with the limits of a medium’s time and/or memory capacity to deliver a unique musical message to the recipient: an obvious, if unspoken, admission of infatuation; an offering of solace for a depressed friend; a set-up for a dance party; a getting-to-know-you gift to an interesting new acquaintance. And I was also one of those young people who vehemently maintained that I would never become another statistic who lost interest in new music somewhere around the age of thirty.
Here I am now, though, a former music fiend who might get in a few minutes a week listening to college or free-form stations. Although I’m not entirely sure what finally caused my former, passionate commitment to just dissipate, it has something to do with COVID, at the beginning of which I was so weirdly traumatized that I was unable to listen to anything with words at all, whether music or plain talk. And I’m guessing there’s also something there about no longer needing music to speak for me, or for all those overwhelming young-person emotions that make you feel freakish about pretty much everything, much less about admitting to or talking about any of it. I have, in other words, grown if not old, at least stereotypically middle-aged.
But here we go anyway, semi-ready to take on a challenge. At this point, I don’t have a main criterion for including songs, which will fall in no particular order—but I’m guessing some themes might occur, one of which will probably be the singer’s good fit with my own vocal range, since I also can’t help singing along to pretty much anything I like. (And also, after days’ worth of piddling about, I’ve come to the conclusion that I’m going to have to do this gradually or not at all—so I’ll offer here what will hopefully be the first of a series of partial lists that will eventually add up to twenty songs.)
1. Kate Bush: “Cloudbusting”
At first I was amazed I included this one, much less started out with it. But then I understood that the song’s repeated assertion that “I just know that something good is gonna happen / I don’t know when, but just saying it could even make it happen” pretty much encapsulates what music was doing for me throughout my young life: letting me hold onto the tune’s expressed faith in the near, good future everyone in my generation had essentially been promised—or if not complete fulfillment, then something beyond loneliness. Combine that with “every time it rains / you’re here in my head” and Bush’s build-up and slightly not-pop style, and you’ve got an anthem of young adult longing that’s a little bit different from the Top 40 stuff that couldn’t help you maintain faith in anything at all.
2. P. J. Harvey: “You Said Something”
OK, longing of a different sort. And in addition to this being one of the few songs I can play and sing while I’m doing it, it’s just such a clear evocation of mood and possibilities—of one of those occasions whose significance you know, even while it’s happening, will stay with you for as long as your brain continues functioning. You’ll lose touch with the people there with you; you might even forget exactly what the really important thing was that was said—but the immersive spirit and all those pressing feelings—maybe some of the only truths we can hold onto—will always remain. “A rooftop in Brooklyn / one in the morning / watching the lights flash / in Manhattan.” Although I’ve never been on a rooftop in Brooklyn, recalling any of a number of rooftops spent late-night with friends in rare conversation puts me right back into that place of being fully and passionately, even if quietly, convinced that the moment, your life, even, is significant, and that there’s greater meaning burbling beneath the surface of the simplest ways of passing the time. “I’m doing nothing wrong / riding in your car / the radio playing / we sing up to the eighth floor.” And then I’m once again drunk on Harvey’s voice: that range that’s so close to my own, I can almost believe we’d understand each other just by that chance anatomy-based similarity that’s neither here nor there.
3. Fleetwood Mac: “Gypsy”
OK, look, it’s impossible for me to decide which of this band’s songs is my favorite, or has had the most impact on any aspect of my life. “Seven Wonders” or “Little Lies” are both strong contenders, as are “I Don’t Want to Know” and “Secondhand News,” all for different reasons, but most of which have Stevie Nicks’s inimitable, amazing voice right out front. This one is all about nostalgia that you dip into, that helps you recognize who you were and how you’ve gotten to now—but instead of getting trapped in reverie, you appreciate what’s been and can move on.
4. David Bowie: “Queen Bitch”
That driving bass line—that bass line! I can’t quite describe the fantastic feelings behind what seems like this song’s full embrace of living into music and all the scenes and scenarios it enables—and Wes Anderson’s use of it in the closing scenes of The Life Aquatic (a film that would itself make it into my top 20) was the perfect victory anthem. So many Bowie songs enable that full immersion in the music, but this one has long remained tops for me.
5. The Smiths: “Ask”
It’s always hard to pick a representative Smiths song; as the title of Simon Goddard’s book had it, theirs were the songs that saved my [teenage] life. Although “There Is a Light that Never Goes Out” is a mainstay, it may be falling out of favor in comparison to some of the band’s others, because the desperately lonely-longing feelings it conjures were thankfully so particular to young adulthood that when reminded of the tune at all, I’m just glad I’m not in its emotional space anymore. And much as I might hate to admit it, The Smiths/Morrissey are ever less a part of my present life—maybe because I don’t feel like the embrace of all that sadness (or “terrible sincerity,” as Morrissey called it on a late-night talk show he was on to promote You Are the Quarry—itself what I consider Mozza’s last truly great album) does me much good anymore, even if the peppy music backing it all is still tremendous. I think my devotion finally came apart after reading Morrissey’s autobiography (which could have done without, as a friend called it, the re-litigation of The Smiths trial), and hearing too many accounts of his apparently race/culture-related crankiness. But I still do very much need “Ask”‘s reminder that “shyness can stop you / from doing all the things in life you’d like to.”
6. The Violent Femmes: “Kiss Off”
There’s no better song for yelling out when you’re feeling hurt or frustrated or angry—and recognize, even as you’re in the midst of it all and even kind of cultivating the mad whirlwind you’re whipping up, that you might just be acting a tad paranoid and/or self-centered. (After all, in counting off your hurts, you “forget what eight was for.”) A quintessential song, in other words, for teens to let off steam—or adults who understand that dancing around and singing off key is a better alternative than, say, punching a wall or pacing around muttering.
7. Portishead: “Glory Box”
Maybe the best way of describing what this song provided (and still provides?) me as a young adult was a model of stylishly alluring indifference, or rather, an example of someone who’s ceased to be overpowered by emotions and illusions. That’s an odd thing to say, given the song’s determination to “give my heart away,” and the longing in Beth Gibbons’s voice that comes out in the chorus. But the additional, and I say fundamental, creepily-spoken decision to “leave it to the other girls to play” was what I still keep hearing and hold onto.
8. Otis Redding: “Cigarettes and Coffee”
Was there ever a better conjuration of what it feels like to talk all night with someone you’re totally comfortable with, to want to be nowhere else and with no one else? I think that’s all I really need to say about this one; we should all be so lucky to have experienced, even once, exactly what’s going on here.
Right: I’ve got the other twelve songs queued up, but this little list is all I can handle at the moment. I’ll do my best to send out another dispatch soon.